Redding Tai Chi

Discover the Timeless
Art of Tai Chi

Is the Short Form Better?

Published by

on

A group of women practicing Tai Chi outdoors in Xi'an, China
Tai Chi, Xi’an, China, May 2024 Redding Tai Chi

Recently, I came across a video on YouTube where the instructor mentioned that the Yang-style long form is very difficult to learn. This view surprised me because, historically, the long form was the cornerstone of Tai Chi instruction. From its development in the mid-1800s until the introduction of shorter forms in the 1950s, it was the only form taught. In my experience, anyone with consistent practice and a well-structured teaching approach can master the long form. Challenges often arise when instructors fail to present the material in an accessible way, or when students don’t dedicate enough time to practice between lessons. More often, it’s a combination of both factors that hinders progress.

The Yang-style long form is like a book where each movement tells an essential part of the story. The three sections of the form are like chapters, with each section building on the last to create a complete and cohesive narrative. While shorter forms can be viewed as abridged versions that give practitioners an overview, they inevitably leave out key elements. These missing movements often contain subtleties that provide deeper insights into the form’s martial applications, energy cultivation, and internal principles.

By practicing the full long form, you gain a more comprehensive understanding of Tai Chi. Each movement, transition, and sequence contributes to mastering body mechanics, breath coordination, and the integration of mind and intent. The long form promotes patience and mindfulness, allowing for greater refinement of postures and alignment.

Although shorter forms offer convenience and accessibility, they cannot replace the depth and richness of the traditional long form. Just as abridging a book removes key plot points and nuances, shortening the Tai Chi form omits essential aspects necessary for truly mastering the art.

Article updated 12/3/24


Discover more from Redding Tai Chi

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 responses to “Is the Short Form Better?”

  1. Dennis Avatar
    Dennis

    I would say that a short form preps your body and mind for the longer form. Also, for some, like seniors learning the form, the short form is preferred.

    Like

  2. alanludmer Avatar
    alanludmer

    I have found that all forms are valuable, but short forms can be very helpful in introducing students to principles and showing them how to integrate principles into movement. You may find the following article of interest.

    With respect.

    https://violetlitaichi.com/the-short-form-solution/

    Like

Leave a reply to Dennis Cancel reply